Gift Cards, Store Credit and Pre-Paid Cards NZ Guide

🎁 Gift Cards, Store Credit and Pre-Paid Cards

Gift cards and store credit look like money but behave very differently. A $100 gift card is a promise by one retailer to provide up to $100 worth of stuff. A $100 note is universally accepted. That difference matters when retailers close, raise prices, or charge monthly "inactivity fees" that eat unused balances. Multi-store pre-paid cards like the Prezzy Card add fees of their own. This guide covers how gift cards work under NZ law, the expiry and fee rules, why retailers love them (breakage income), what happens in liquidation (Smith & Caughey's 2024, Smiths City 2024), and when a gift card is actually a rip-off.

                Key Point: Gift cards and store credit in NZ must have a minimum 3-year expiry by law (Fair Trading Act 2022 amendment). "Inactivity fees" must be disclosed clearly. If the retailer goes into liquidation, gift card holders become unsecured creditors - typically recovering 0-20 cents on the dollar. Recent NZ liquidations wiped out hundreds of thousands of dollars of gift card value: Smith & Caughey's and Smiths City in 2024. Prezzy Card and similar general-purpose cards carry monthly fees ($3-$5) after the first year that erode balances. Gift cards are worse money than cash: they can expire, they can disappear with a retailer, they carry fees, they're harder to replace if lost. Use them fast or use something else.
            

What a Gift Card Actually Is

Legally, a gift card is a voucher representing a prepaid amount, redeemable with a specific retailer (or group of retailers for multi-store cards). The retailer holds your money; you hold a promise.

Type	How It Works	Example
Single-retailer gift card	Redeemable only at that retailer	Kathmandu, Whitcoulls, The Warehouse
Multi-store group card	Redeemable across a group's chains	Foodstuffs (New World/Pak'nSave), Woolworths
Mall card	Redeemable at any store in the mall	Westfield GiftCard, Sylvia Park card
General-purpose pre-paid	Works like a Visa/Mastercard anywhere	Prezzy Card, EPay Visa
Store credit	Refund issued as credit with the retailer	When you return a faulty item without receipt

NZ Law on Gift Card Expiry

From June 2022, amendments to the Fair Trading Act 1986 set new rules:

Gift cards must have at least 3 years' validity from date of issue (or be indefinite)
Any expiry date must be clearly displayed on the card
Any fees must be disclosed at point of sale
Applies to gift cards sold by NZ retailers (does not apply to cards issued under loyalty programmes for free, nor to gift cards from overseas retailers)

Before 2022, some cards had 12-month expiries. The new law made those unlawful. However, the 3-year minimum doesn't mean free money - cards that expire after 3 years with unused balances still belong to the retailer.

Why Retailers Love Gift Cards: Breakage Income

"Breakage" is the industry term for gift card balances that never get redeemed. Industry studies estimate:

10% to 20% of gift card value is never redeemed
Forgotten cards, lost cards, cards below the minimum spend all contribute
Retailers record breakage as revenue - pure profit
A retailer selling $10 million in gift cards keeps about $1.5 million in breakage

This is why almost every retailer pushes gift cards. They're not being nice - they're leveraging your inertia for revenue.

Company sells $5,000,000 in gift cards annually

Average breakage rate: 12%

Money received but never redeemed: $600,000/year

Plus: customers spend more than card value on 60% of redemptions

Plus: customers redeem in-store (not online) so higher margin

Gift cards are extremely profitable for retailers

Lost or Stolen Gift Cards

Most NZ gift cards are bearer instruments - whoever holds the card can use it. Unlike cash, a lost card usually cannot be replaced by the retailer. Some retailers offer "registered" gift cards where you can link your identity, but many do not.

Practical implication: Treat gift cards like cash. Keep them secure. Register the card online where possible to enable replacement if lost.

⚠️ Fees, Inactivity Traps and Liquidation Risks

Prezzy Card and General-Purpose Pre-Paid Cards

The Prezzy Card is the most popular general-purpose gift card in NZ. It works like a Visa debit card - usable wherever Visa is accepted. Popular as corporate gifts and for flexibility. Here's what to know about the fees:

Fee Type	Amount	When It Applies
Purchase/issuance fee	$5 to $10	Charged at purchase
Inactivity fee	$2 to $5/month	After 6 to 12 months of no use
Balance enquiry fee	$0 to $1 each	Depends on card brand
Overseas/FX fee	2.5% to 4%	International transactions
Replacement fee	$10 to $20	If lost or damaged

The insidious bit: A $100 Prezzy Card sat in a drawer for 18 months could have $5 to $10 eaten by inactivity fees before you use it. A $50 card forgotten for 3 years might have nothing left.

Tips for Maximising Pre-Paid Card Value

Spend it within the first few months
If you receive one, use it or convert it to something useful immediately
Register online if the option exists - often waives some fees and enables replacement
Avoid balance below $10 - small balances often get eaten by fees first
Don't give general-purpose pre-paid cards as gifts - cash or bank transfer has none of these problems

When a Retailer Goes Into Liquidation

When a retailer fails, gift card holders become unsecured creditors - at the bottom of the priority list. Typical recovery: 0 to 20 cents on the dollar, if any.

Smith & Caughey's Liquidation (2024)

The historic Queen Street department store Smith & Caughey's entered liquidation in 2024 after 144 years of trading.

Hundreds of gift cards, vouchers, and store credits were outstanding
Gift card holders joined the line of unsecured creditors behind employees, tax authorities, and secured creditors
Preliminary liquidator reports indicated very limited expected payout to unsecured creditors
Customers who had received cards as wedding gifts, Christmas gifts, or work bonuses largely lost the value

Smiths City Liquidation (2024)

Furniture and appliances retailer Smiths City entered liquidation in mid-2024.

Outstanding store credits, gift cards, and deposits on ordered goods were all affected
Customers who had paid deposits on big-ticket items (couches, appliances) were particularly hurt
Deposits of $500 to $5,000+ were lost by many customers
Credit card chargebacks were a partial recovery route for those who had used them

Mico Plumbing (2023)

Trade supply chain Mico entered liquidation, affecting mainly trade customers with outstanding deposits and account credit. Limited consumer exposure but similar pattern.

What To Do If Your Retailer Enters Liquidation

If you paid by credit card: Contact your bank immediately for chargeback (works if within 90-120 days)
If you have a gift card: Consider spending it IMMEDIATELY before liquidators close doors (retailers often keep trading briefly)
If you have store credit: Same - redeem as fast as possible
If you paid a deposit for goods not yet delivered: File a claim in the liquidation as unsecured creditor
Keep all documentation: Receipts, bank statements, email correspondence
Check company liquidation notices: Companies Office publishes liquidator contact details

Recovery Reality Check

For Smith & Caughey's, Smiths City, and similar cases:

Typical recovery for unsecured creditors: 0 to 20 cents on the dollar

Many liquidations pay nothing to unsecured creditors

$500 gift card might recover $0 to $100

Credit card chargeback: 100% recovery if within timeframe

Bank transfer or cash: typically 0% recovery

Red Flags That a Retailer Might Fail

Not always obvious, but warning signs:

Heavy discounting (70% off everything) over extended period
Reduced product range on shelves
Staff reductions visible
Media reports of financial difficulty
Closed stores in chain while others remain
Owners publicly raising capital or seeking buyers
Delayed payment to suppliers (sometimes reported)

If you see any of these with a retailer you hold gift cards for, spend them immediately.

Consumer Protection Gap

NZ has no consumer compensation scheme for gift cards. Unlike bank deposits (protected to $100,000 from 2024), gift cards carry full retailer risk. Advocacy groups have called for a reserve fund or insurance scheme, but no such protection exists.

💸 When Gift Cards Are a Rip-Off (And When They're Okay)

The Case Against Gift Cards

Consider a $100 retailer gift card vs $100 cash:

Feature	$100 Gift Card	$100 Cash
Where to spend	Only at specific retailer	Anywhere
Expiry	Yes (3 years min)	Never
Fees	Possible inactivity/issuance fees	None
If lost	Usually no replacement	Lost
Retailer failure risk	Near-total loss	No risk
Conversion to cash	Very hard, usually at loss	Already cash
Purchase price freedom	Often spend MORE than card value	Full control

When Gift Cards Are Actually Worth It

Despite the risks, gift cards have some legitimate uses:

As a specific gift idea: Giving a book lover $100 at Whitcoulls signals thought and directs toward enjoyment
Discounted resale: Cards often trade on secondary markets at 5-15% below face value
Loyalty redemption: Using points earned via Fly Buys/Airpoints for specific retailer cards
Budget control: Physical limits on spending can work for disciplined spenders
Experience gifts: Restaurant, cinema, airline gift cards direct to experiences
Specific retailer cards when buyer has loyalty/will definitely use

When Gift Cards Are Almost Always a Rip-Off

When the recipient doesn't regularly shop at that retailer
Small-value cards ($20 to $50) - often forgotten or hit with fees
Cards from retailers in financial difficulty
General-purpose pre-paid (Prezzy etc.) where cash achieves same with no fees
Cards bought at second-hand markup where face value doesn't make sense
Cards bought with credit card points at unfavourable conversion ratios

Better Alternatives to Gift Cards

Cash: Universally usable, no fees, no expiry, works if retailer fails
Bank transfer: Like cash but safer than sending physical notes
Specific product: If you know they want something, buy it
Experience gift: Dinner out, concert tickets, direct to the provider
Service subscription: Spotify, Netflix - the platform itself isn't going anywhere
A handwritten card with cash: Classic and unbeatable

If You Already Have Gift Cards, Here's How to Maximise Them

Spend immediately. Risk increases with time
Spend the full balance. Small remainders get forgotten or eaten by fees
Use towards something you'd have bought anyway. Don't let the card drive unnecessary purchases
Check retailer stability. If rumours of trouble, spend faster
Register online if possible. Enables tracking and sometimes replacement
Stack on top of sales. Use cards during actual sales for maximum value
Consider resale if unwanted. Apps like Card Cash, and FB Marketplace facilitate resale at 80-95% of face value

Receiving Store Credit (Refund Credits)

When you return a faulty product and the retailer issues "store credit" instead of refund:

Under the Consumer Guarantees Act, for faulty goods you're entitled to refund of original payment method - NOT store credit - for major faults
Retailers often push store credit because it keeps your money with them
Don't accept store credit for faulty goods unless you actively prefer it
For change-of-mind returns (not a CGA right), store credit is often the only offer available - still better than nothing

Gift Cards Given to You as Rewards

Gift cards sometimes appear as part of competitions, surveys or loyalty programmes:

"Earn a $20 gift card for completing this survey"
"Receive a $50 gift card for opening an account"
"Get a $100 gift card when you switch services"

These are marketing costs for the company. Use them or forget them - they're genuinely free money. But be aware the value you spend often exceeds the card value (you add your own money to get the product), which is exactly what retailers count on.

The Annual Gift Card Audit

Once a year, gather all gift cards you own:

Check the remaining balance (retailer website or phone)
Check expiry dates
Spend cards at risk of expiry first
Resell cards you won't use (Card Cash, Marketplace)
Total your gift card portfolio - often more than people realise
Plan purchases that will fully consume the balance

Australian data suggests the average household carries about $300 to $500 in forgotten gift card value. NZ is probably similar. An annual audit recovers real money.

🔢 Worked Examples and Real-World Stories

Example 1: The True Cost of Breakage

You receive a $50 gift card. Probability analysis:

Chance used fully: 60%

Chance partially used (average $15 unused): 25%

Chance forgotten entirely: 15%

Expected value: (60% × $50) + (25% × $35) + (15% × $0)

= $30 + $8.75 + $0 = $38.75

Expected received value: $38.75 (77.5% of face)

Cash gift of $50 = $50 value

Example 2: Prezzy Card Fee Erosion

$100 Prezzy Card received, forgotten for 2 years.

Initial balance: $100

First 12 months: no fee

Months 13-24: $4/month inactivity fee × 12 = $48

Balance after 2 years: $52

Spend it within 12 months to keep full value

Example 3: Retailer Liquidation Impact

Family holding $650 Smith & Caughey's gift card when closure announced (2024).

Voucher purchased 8 months before closure

Paid by EFTPOS (no chargeback possible)

Liquidator recovery estimate: 0 to 20 cents on the dollar

Expected recovery: $0 to $130 out of $650

Most likely outcome: near-total loss

If bought by credit card: full $650 recovery possible via chargeback (if within 120 days)

Example 4: Resale Market Value

Received $100 Hallenstein Brothers gift card, don't shop there.

Option A: Keep and forget. Risk: expiry/loss. Expected value: $50 to $80

Option B: Sell on Facebook Marketplace at 85% of face: net $85 cash

Option C: Use card, adding $20+ of own money for useful item: get $100 value, spend $20 extra

Option D: Gift to someone who will use it: give 100% value

Best options: sell, gift, or use deliberately

Worst option: let it sit until it's worth $20

Example 5: The Overspend Trap

$50 gift card, item wanted is $85.

Path 1: Use card, pay $35 from own money, get $85 item

Path 2: Buy $50 item, keep card for $0 more spend

Retailer wins with Path 1 (more revenue)

Customer pays $35 extra that may not have been spent otherwise

Industry data: about 60% of redemptions are over-spend

Average additional spend per redemption: $20 to $40

Real-World Story: The Wedding Gift Card Disaster

Anna and Jake's $800 Voucher

Received Smith & Caughey's gift card as wedding gift (2024). Store closed 5 months later.

What Happened:

Card held for wedding registry / home items
Planned to use during post-wedding settling in
Smith & Caughey's announcement came 5 months after wedding
Already within the 6-week wind-down period
Scrambled to spend the card during closing sales

Result:

Managed to use $520 before final closure

Bought items they didn't fully need to maximise the value

Remaining $280 balance: lost

Ultimate recovery: $520 of $800 (65%)

Lesson: Even "fancy" department stores can close. Gift cards held for "someday" have real risk. If you're given a significant gift card, ring-fence a plan to use it within 6 months. 'Settling in' after a wedding took too long.

Real-World Story: The Inactivity Fee Surprise

Tom's Drawer Find

Found a $150 Prezzy Card from a work bonus, forgotten in a drawer.

The Discovery:

Card found 3 years after issue
Logged into Prezzy site to check balance
Balance: $42
Statement showed 30 months of $3.50 inactivity fees = $105

Options Remaining:

Spend remaining $42 within a few months before more fees

Of original $150, about 28% remaining

No way to recover lost fees

Company profited $105 from one forgotten card

Lesson: General-purpose pre-paid cards need to be used within 12 months or fees destroy value. Corporate bonuses in Prezzy Card form are actually worth less than the face value over time. Cash or direct bank transfer is always better.

Real-World Story: The Credit Card Chargeback Save

Maria's Smiths City Deposit

Paid $2,800 deposit on a dining set at Smiths City. Liquidation announced 5 weeks later.

What She Did:

Paid by credit card (crucial)
Saw liquidation announcement, immediately contacted bank
Submitted chargeback request within 10 days
Provided documentation: deposit receipt, emails about delivery

Result:

Bank reversed the $2,800 charge within 30 days

Full recovery (would have been zero via liquidation)

Other customers who paid by EFTPOS or cash: lost their deposits

Liquidation creditors received near-zero

Lesson: For any significant purchase or deposit (over $100-$200), always pay by credit card. The chargeback protection is worth more than any points or cashback you might earn. In this case it was literally the difference between $2,800 recovery and $0.

Real-World Story: The Gift Card Arbitrage

Ben's Smart Strategy

Received multiple gift cards to stores he doesn't use.

The Stack:

$150 Kathmandu (not an outdoor person)
$50 Lush (doesn't use bath products)
$100 Bunnings (renter, not a DIY person)
Total face value: $300

His Strategy:

Listed all three on Facebook Marketplace at 90% face value

Sold all within 2 weeks for $270 total cash

Instead of forgetting cards worth $0 to $100 net

Or force-spending $300 at stores he didn't want to shop at

Net recovery: $270 cash for things he actually wanted

Lesson: Don't force yourself to use gift cards at stores you don't love. The secondary market (Facebook Marketplace, Trade Me, Card Cash) recovers 80-95% of face value in cash. Ten minutes listing beats a year of unused cards.

🎯 Test Your Knowledge

Quiz on Gift Cards, Store Credit and Pre-Paid Cards

1. What's the minimum gift card expiry under NZ law (from 2022)?

6 months

1 year

3 years

Indefinite - no expiry allowed

2. What's "breakage" in the gift card industry?

Cards physically damaged and unusable

Card value that's never redeemed (pure profit for the retailer)

Transaction processing fees

A specific type of card

3. If a retailer goes into liquidation, gift card holders are:

Compensated fully by the government

Unsecured creditors, typically recovering 0-20 cents on the dollar

First in line to be paid

Reimbursed by another retailer

4. After 12 months, a Prezzy Card typically applies what?

Automatic balance return

Monthly inactivity fees ($2-$5) that erode the balance

Bonus top-up

Nothing changes

5. If you paid a deposit at a retailer that then liquidated, what's your best recovery path?

Sue the owners personally

Credit card chargeback if you paid by credit card

Complain to Consumer NZ

Wait for government compensation

6. Which NZ retailer's 2024 liquidation affected many gift card holders?

The Warehouse

Farmers

Smith & Caughey's

Briscoes

7. For faulty goods under the CGA, can retailers force you to accept store credit instead of a refund?

Yes, for any return

No - for major faults you're entitled to refund in original payment method

Only if the receipt is missing

Yes for sale items

8. Why do about 60% of gift card redemptions cost the customer MORE than the card value?

Hidden charges

Customers add their own money to reach the product they want

Cards have processing fees at checkout

Higher prices apply to card-paying customers

9. What's the best alternative to giving a gift card as a gift?

Cash, bank transfer, or a specific item they want

A bigger gift card

A Prezzy Card

Multiple smaller gift cards

10. If you have a gift card for a store you don't use, what's the smart move?

Let it expire eventually

Force yourself to shop there

Sell it on Facebook Marketplace at 80-95% face value, or regift

Demand a refund from the retailer

📖 Consumer Protection

If you've found a bug, or would like to contact us, or learn more about James Graham and Calculate.co.nz.

Calculate.co.nz is partnered with Interest.co.nz for New Zealand's highest quality calculators and financial analysis.

All calculators and tools are provided for educational and indicative purposes only and do not constitute financial advice.

Calculate.co.nz is proudly part of the Realtor.co.nz group, New Zealand's leading property transaction literacy platform, helping Kiwis understand the home buying and selling process from start to finish. Whether you're a first home buyer navigating your first property purchase, an investor evaluating your next acquisition, or a homeowner planning to sell, Realtor.co.nz provides clear, independent, and trustworthy guidance on every step of the New Zealand property transaction journey.

Calculate.co.nz is also partnered with Health Based Building and Premium Homes to promote informed choices that lead to better long-term outcomes for Kiwi households.

All content on this website, including calculators, tools, source code, and design, is protected under the Copyright Act 1994 (New Zealand). No part of this site may be reproduced, copied, distributed, stored, or used in any form without prior written permission from the owner.